MY EXPERIENCE WITH THE RAW FOOD DIET
This is my response to a question Marina posed in her blog in regards to raw food and its abilty to reverse diabetes natturally, and whether it was sustainable. As well as some of my own experiences being on a raw food diet.
I believe it is sustainable, if you just keep up the eating habit. Of course in this video, these individuals were at a facility/house where they were provided their meals everyday. Their environment made the process a little easier, since they had no other options to eat.
But talking from experience, being on a raw food diet can be difficult to maintain for many reasons, for example, temptation, financial, access, or lack of creativity. Even to begin the diet and make it a habit is difficult as we saw in the video.
But once someone makes a committment to change, this type of diet can do wonders. I currently have 4 friends that have been on a raw food diet for about 2 years now. They are extremely healthy and active people.
I believe one can definitely reverse diseases such as diabetes, but it will definitely come back if you revert back to the same eating patterns as before. So it is temporary if you choose to do the diet on a temporary basis. If you really want to make lifetime changes, I believe you have to make it a lifetime decision.
I was actually on an 80% raw food diet myself, and during that time it was the best that I have ever felt. My reasons for not sticking to the diet anymore is simply because I started to hang out with more people that weren't raw, therefore it was hard for me to maintain my raw food eating habits. It was my own weakness and addictions to cooked food. But for 1 year I maintained the raw food diet. I constantly tell myself that I want to go back and move more towards that kind of diet, because I know the positive effects it had on my body. I felt I had a lot more energy, and I hardly got sick. And since I was also working out, my body had never looked so great. It was actually during this time that I also lost a lot of weight. (I was a size 14 at one point, but as soon as I stopped drinking soda, I started loosing a lot of weight. Then i stopped eating red meat, and again the same affects. But the raw food diet really made me get down to my ideal weight. Size 7.) It is definitely possible to go back to those eating habits, but I just have to be diciplined about it. I think mostly during the time I was on the diet, it was because I had a strong support network. During that time most of my friends were either on that diet or were striving towards it.
Those that recommend the raw food diet, advocate that fresh vegetables and fruits, along with raw nuts, sprouted beans, or anything that hasn't been cooked (but vegetarian foods) have "live" enzymes that help your body process the food better, and maximizes your uptake of the nutritious contents of the foods.
But I do agree with Marina about having more investigations on this topic. I remember wanting to learn more, and I would enter raw food in OVID a few years back and I couldn't find much. Today, there were a few articles that I found. Here are some of them.
Some supportive evidence of positive health affects of eating raw food vegetables:
Salad and Raw Vegetable Consumption and Nutritional Status in the Adult US Population: Results from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
Journal of the American Dietetic Association, Volume 106, Issue 9, Pages 1394-1404
L. Su, L. Arab
Hobbs SH. Attitudes, practices, and beliefs of individuals consuming a raw foods diet. [Journal Article] Explore-The Journal of Science & Healing. 1(4):272-7, 2005 Jul.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: Describe dietary practices of U.S. raw foods leaders, examine diet rationale, attitudes and health practices of raw foodists. DESIGN: Nonexperimental, descriptive, using semistructured qualitative interview data. PARTICIPANTS: Purposeful (nonrandom) sample of 17 U.S. raw foods leaders, including 11 males and 6 females. Leaders were targeted to provide insights into practices modeled for larger community. PHENOMENA OF INTEREST: Attitudes, practices, and beliefs of individuals consuming a raw foods diet. ANALYSIS: Text analysis and simple descriptive statistics. RESULTS: Subjects averaged 13 years on the diet (range: 3-32 years). Twelve subjects reported a diet at least 85% raw. All diets were primarily vegan. Primary constituents included fruits and juices, vegetables, nuts and seeds, and vegetable fats. Subjects consumed no dairy, eggs, meat, fish, poultry, commercial sweets or alcohol in a typical week. Only one subject used a commercial, nonfood-based supplement weekly (vitamin B12). Six subjects consumed food-based supplements, and remainder used no supplements at all. On average, subjects met or exceeded recommended intakes of vegetables, fruits, and fats and did not meet recommendations for calcium-rich foods, protein-rich foods, and grains. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Those counseling raw foodists must understand the rationale and practices that characterize this eating style. Further research is needed on larger populations to validate findings and determine the extent to which reported health benefits may compare to those from other vegetarian diets. Further studies should examine food-handling and preparation practices in relation to food safety and raw produce
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
11 comments:
Hi Yaneth, I think that you have some very powerful points about the raw diet lifestyle. The number one being that in order to reap the benefits of this truly cleansing or detoxing regime, it's a lifestyle and not a fad diet.
In the 30-day... kiss diabetes goodbye documentary... we, the audience, only saw the short term impacts of the participants (beating diabetetes types 2), but were there effects (eliminating diabetes from their lives') long term outcomes? Will they never have diabetes again. We don't know, but I would guess probably becuase these kinds of unique experiences usually accompany lifestyle changes. It worked so severly because the participants were sort of like lab rats, secluded from society and all temptation - which is a way to skew average data.
I, myself, have never tried to stick with a raw diet, for the reasons you stated, it can be poor in taste quality, it may be too challenging to find that kind of food ingredients or restaurants and is a bit pricy. But I have so much praise for people who can and do.
Hi Yaneth,
Thanks for sharing your experience with eating raw foods. Its funny because earlier this week I just decided to eat more raw foods and then all of a sudden i stumbled upon your blogs. Carrots are my current favorite snack. What's great is that whenever I'm home my mom likes to make me fresh juice in our juicer. I think that would be a great way to add variety into a raw foods diet. Great blog.
I agree with both you and Alexis that whatever change is made, it has to be a change in a lifestyle. Diets don't work and actually cause more harm than good. I'm really interested in exploring this more. Thank you for addressing this in your blog.
Hola hermana,
Thanks for writing this blog. I have always wondered what the "real-life" effects were to the raw food diet. And by "real-life" I mean actually hearing it from someone I know! I have been playing with the idea of becoming vegetarian, but after about 2 days of eating that way, I get these MASSIVE protein cravings for a cheeseburger! ahhaha!
I admire your stamina and the perseverance you experienced in your raw diet times...You're such an example for all of us!
As I reflect on the video, I remember thinking what the documentary's participants did when they went home. It was stated there was follow up, but when will that be released if at all? Did they teach them diet sustainability? I believe learning those tools could be the most important part of that intervention.
Tlazocomatli,
Andrea
Yaneth, thanks so much ofr sharing your expereince with us. Latley I been hear a lot about the raw diet, but having hte opportunity of listening to yours teach me alto about it.
Yaneth, thanks so much ofr sharing your expereince with us. Latley I been hear a lot about the raw diet, but having hte opportunity of listening to yours teach me alto about it.
I had honestly never really heard of anyone sticking to a raw food diet before I read this blog entry. I assumed that most veggies have to be cooked, like asparagus, brocolli, and squashes. kudos to you for doing it for the amount of time that you did. Like you I understand the endless benefits from eating healthy. I only wish others could stand with us and give up the crispy fried chicken foods that instantly gratify our tastebuds and instead eat healthy foods that may help them be more energetic and happy.
Yaneth, thank you for sharing your experience, I am very interested in nutrition and health. I love to try different diets, especially the ones that boost the amount of energy and how you feel. I am glad that I read your blog! Looking forward to get on the raw diet and hopefully see the difference in my body!
Interesting study - 13 years on average? That's impressive... they must really believe in the diet as an integral aspect of their daily lives... It'd be interesting to see the health outcomes on a larger populations...
I think it might actually be possible to do psychological expts to make someone enjoy the raw food diet and abstain from unhealthy food. Somethings I think my cravings are a getting a little out of hand. and I would definitely go with psychological expts if they are effective.
Thanks for your perspective. I couldn't imagine being able to make that change but I agree with you, changing ones lifestyle really must be a lifetime commitment.
Post a Comment